ERP Implementation Strategies: Big Bang vs. Phased
BIG BANG STRATEGY:
Big bang ERP go-live strategy is the one where all of the main modules of an ERP system go live at the same time.
A phased approach describes a scenario where elements or modules of the ERP system are introduced in a planned sequence, replacing the old systems gradually.
Feasibility of a strategy is based on the following factors:
1. Impact on the organisation
A big bang approach exerts additional pressure on the business and the project team during the cutover – simply because there’s so much activity going on all at once. A phased approach can lead to quick wins, which provides confidence and helps in selling the advantages to the rest of the organisation. On the other hand, poor experiences in early phases can lead to negativity around the ERP project and in a worst case scenario it could even undermine a rollout plan.
2. Temporary Interfaces:
Phased implementations often require temporary interfaces to provide temporary working solution. It is costly to implement temporary interfaces.
Phased strategy implementation takes longer time than big bang strategy. Factors such as regulatory compliances, acquisitions, new product introductions and other capital expenditure programs can influence the required timescale for an ERP implementation. Planning the project will need to take these other factors into account and could well influence the big bang versus phased decision.
4. Business units
Generally it is easier to manage multi-site and multi-business unit implementations in a phased manner. Except for the scenario involving a hub site with satellite or regional sites dependent on the hub, it may be easier to go big bang for this full group of sites due to the interdependencies involved.
Phased implementations levy:
- Additional external costs
- Additional internal costs
- Additional costs for temporary interfaces
Generally big bang implementations are much riskier than phased implementations.
- It’s more difficult to revert to the old system if everything goes wrong.
- There’s a higher risk of serious damage to the business.
- Full end-to-end testing is much more difficult to achieve
- A big bang go-live places a huge strain on all parts of the organization
If you’re interested in implementing an ERP system and want a consultation, give us a call or reach us using our contact page.